Host Rachelle Hampton talks through reader-submitted gossip with a guest, delivering stories that are juicy, strange, funny and utterly banal about people you will never know and never meet. Created by Kelsey McKinney and Alex Sujong Laughlin, it treats second-hand truth as stranger than fiction and follows strangers' decisions in forensic, affectionate detail.
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Listen on Apple Podcasts Listen on Spotify Official site
What kind of show is it?
A true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, who each week share compelling true crimes alongside hometown stories sent in by friends and listeners. Since launching in January 2016 it has covered infamous serial killers such as the Night Stalker, cold cases, cults, survivor stories and events including the Tulsa race massacre of 1921.
Why we like it
My Favorite Murder works because it never pretends true crime is a clean genre. Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark talk about murder the way obsessed friends actually do, with horror, jokes, digressions, corrections and sudden seriousness when a detail deserves it. That mix is the format, and across 1,248 episodes, refreshed roughly every three days, it has built a back catalogue that runs from the Night Stalker and long-cold cases to cults, survivor accounts and the Tulsa race massacre of 1921. Alongside the main editions, numbered 559 by 19 November 2026, there are Minisodes built from listeners' hometown stories and Rewind episodes revisiting earlier instalments, so the archive offers several different ways in. Episodes are long, often an hour to well over two hours, and they are meant to be lived with rather than skimmed: this is company for a long drive or a slow afternoon, not background noise. New listeners sometimes worry the comedy will undercut the victims. In practice the humour is aimed at the hosts themselves and at the absurdity around a case, while the storytelling keeps returning to the people harmed. If you want forensic detachment, choose something else. If you want to feel like you are in the room, start here.
Recent episodes
Source: Apple Podcasts / official show RSS(2026-11-19) · Figures as of the check date
You may also like
Julia Louis-Dreyfus hosts funny, touching, personal conversations with iconic older women, drawing on the unapologetic attitude and wisdom that only comes with age. Now in its fourth season and described as award-winning, the show also features her 91-year-old mother, Judith, and its stated rallying cry is simple: all hail old women.
Four presenters, Dan Schreiber, James Harkin, Andrew Hunter Murray and Anna Ptaszynski, each bring the most amazing fact they have learned in the last seven days and discuss them together. The show describes itself as a multi award-winning, globe-travelling phenomenon with 600 million downloads, and it is a programme about, in its own words, everything.